Capitalism Under Fire III

I probably should’ve started here. Any discussion of capitalism assumes people understand the role of capital. This may be a false assumption. Ask your friends or others to define or describe capital. You might get a blank stare, or something like, “Oh, that’s stocks and bonds.” Can you define or describe it?

Apparently, this lack of awareness is widespread. I asked AI whether many Americans could describe economic capital. The answer is that very few can. On the other hand, surveys show that at least 17% can define socialism, and many more have some idea of it. This knowledge includes Karl Marx’s concepts like his convoluted labor theory of value:

However, capital, unlike Marx, isn’t hard to understand. The easiest way to understand capital is to think of it as foregone consumption. Eons ago, our hunter-gatherer forebears would forage for grains and fruit over distance. At some point, they brought some back closer to the cave. Maybe some dropped on the ground, and new plants grew. Someone noticed and, rather than eating everything on later forays, planted some of the seeds instead. When the crop ripened, the planter saved some of the harvest for the next crop, again foregoing consumption; in agriculture, we called the saved amount seed corn. In economics, we call it capital.

If you want similar crops in the future, you save a similar amount of seed, but to grow more, you need more seed, more capital. Growing the tribe’s economy requires ever-expanding seedcorn-capital.

Of course, risk is ever-present. Rats may eat your saved seeds. A flood may wash away the crop. Drought or locusts may loom. Thieves and hostile governments, both foreign and domestic, are ever present. So capital is also a bet on the future. It stands to reason that the most successful farmers can take the biggest risks. Through their knowledge and resources, they have the best chance of overcoming the risks.

Properly assessing the risk-reward ratio is often key to moving forward. The old saying, “nothing ventured, nothing gained,” is true for people and societies. Refusing to take a chance guarantees you won’t make progress.

Continue reading →

Capitalism Under Fire II

No monopoly lasts without government sanction. That’s just a fact. If you can think of one, I’d like to know. In competitive free markets, dominance is fleeting; look at American Online, Sears, IBM, or Microsoft.

You might ask, what about the Gilded Age Robber Barons? Didn’t Standard Oil and U.S. Steel use their dominance to gouge the public? Even then, both competed in the world market and faced plenty of competition. Instead, out of fear of competitors and to reach lower price points that expanded their markets, they lowered their product prices during the period.

Given the thousands of years of government favoritism, patronage, monopolies, and corruption, pointing to Capitalism’s so-called moral deficiencies is laughable. If Government didn’t control so much of the economy, we wouldn’t need the vast army of lobbyists encamped in Washington. All seek some favor or try to prevent others from using Government favor against them. We now mimic a Royal Court, attracting those seeking benefits:

The recent Skydance-Warner Bros merger illustrates how far down the road to corruption we’ve come. The Government, with its power over “monopolies ” and “restraint of trade ” at various levels, seems to have extracted large sums from the Ellisons and their company, Skydance, to ensure completion of a merger they had already committed large sums to.

No one in their right mind thinks the merger could create a media monopoly or meaningfully restrain trade. At 27%, its largest share of any media sub-market, Motion Pictures is hardly a monopoly—just a large entity in a vast market. Still, the Ellisons contributed 45 million dollars to the Trump ’24 election campaign, and more to other Trump-favored endeavors.

Then many states jumped in through their attorneys general, forcing Skydance to commit huge sums for favored constituencies. Doesn’t this sound more like doing business in a banana republic than in the U.S.?

Adam Smith was, in fact, a moral philosopher; he saw greater virtue in businesses serving their customers rather than their rulers. A business that loses its customers’ confidence will go out of business, but if the Government protects it from competition, serving the public matters little. The invisible hand sorts the trustworthy from the rest.

If you order from Amazon today, you expect it to arrive on time at the agreed-upon price. Even as big as it is, it works hard to keep your trust, knowing that if it doesn’t, someone else will. Do you feel the same when you deal with the Government? How about the IRS or the motor vehicle department?

Continue reading →

Capitalism Under Fire I

It is widely reported that Socialism is more popular than ever in the U.S. and is gaining on Capitalism as our preferred economic system. This shift is most prominent among young people, many of whom claim that Capitalism just hasn’t delivered for them. Because of Capitalism’s failures, we are in the middle of an affordability crisis.

While this may make some sense on the surface, a closer look is warranted. Affordability is just another way of saying prices are too high and rising. In other words, Inflation. Economist Milton Friedman famously stated that “inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon,” arguing it results from the money supply growing faster than economic output—too much money chasing too few goods.

Capitalism means the least government interference in the economy. Private enterprise has no control over the money supply. Only the Government, through the Federal Reserve (FED), has that power. The FED is a 1913 progressive creation with a poor record on Inflation:

Except for wars, sustained rising prices were virtually unknown before the FED. In fact, during the Gilded Age, a period with little government interference but amazing growth, prices consistently fell, increasing real wages. Inflation, then, is a government phenomenon. Blaming Capitalism is misplaced. Looking to the Government for solutions flies in he face of experience.

This situation led me to look more closely at the other prevalent criticisms of Capitalism. The first thing you find is this: Adam Smith and his followers, moving away from the government-controlled mercantilist and feudal systems then in existence, never used the term Capitalism. Instead, they used free markets or free enterprise. Smith himself called it a “system of natural liberty.” French socialist Louis Blanc used the word capitalisme around 1850 to mean “the appropriation of capital by some to the exclusion of others.” He obviously meant it as a pejorative.

Maybe this explains why the media and academia use Capitalism rather than free market or free enterprise when referring to an economic system relying on markets to direct investment and set prices?

The Gallup poll shows Socialism’s favorability rising to 43% vs. Capitalism at 53%, while Free Enterprise in the same poll sits at 77%. Yet Capitalism and Free Enterprise are considered synonyms in every dictionary, meaning essentially the same.

Curious, I asked AI what the major failures of Capitalism were touted. They centered on five general n deficiencies. Unequal distribution of Wealth, market failures, prioritizing demand over morality, environmental degradation, and labor exploitation make for quite an indictment.  

Since we aren’t gods and aren’t perfect, a reasonable inquiry into this bill of particulars should ask: compared to what? Has any other system done a better job in these areas?

Continue reading →

Delusions

“If the Republicans win the House of Representatives and the United States Senate, both of them,” President Donald Trump said at his midterm convention, “I will issue a dividend to every adult citizen in the United States of America for $5,000.” As the New York Times (NYT) tells us, in 2020, Democrats in Georgia pointed to $2,000 coronavirus relief checks if their party took control of the Senate. Politicians always promise more cash or other monetary benefits if you’ll vote their way:

The Socialist Party of America (DSA), which exerts more and more influence on the Democratic Party, promises either lots of free stuff or more cash in your pocket through things like greatly expanding the minimum wage. All these promises come against the backdrop of “The Affordability Crisis.”

The crisis is just a way of saying prices are rising faster than our ability to pay them. Both parties point to putting more dollars in everyone’s pockets as the answer. But does this make sense? Say ten people are in line to buy one of the ten parcels of necessities needed to survive. Each has $100; the necessities, to no one’s surprise, cost $100. Now President Trump, or Mayor Mandami, comes along and gives each $50. Everyone has more money in their pockets, but now the price of necessities has risen to $150. Unless supply increases, this is the only outcome.

Donald’s or Zohan’s largesse runs aground because of the Law of Supply and Demand. It still rules, as it has through the ages. Simply put, if Demand exceeds supply, prices will rise. Increasing Demand without more supply keeps prices rising.

Increasing supply to meet or exceed Demand stops inflation. However, this solution requires capital investment. Planting more acreage, building a factory, drilling wells, ships to bring in imported goods, or opening a mine- whatever is needed to increase supply demands capital.

Capital is forgone consumption, or put another way, savings, and the positive returns on them. If you lend at interest or invest directly in assets that grow in value, you have more capital, but you also face the risk of loss. Not every well finds oil, gas, or even water.

Continue reading →

AI In The Crosshairs

While we await the umpteenth peace that Trump has promised since the Iran ceasefire, it might be a good time to address the rising calls to impose controls on Artificial Intelligence (AI) and to reduce the power and wealth of the leaders of the enterprises leading the technology. After all, bringing concentrated knowledge and computing power to the masses can overturn the social order and threaten humanity.

Leaders in both parties appear to be tripping over each other, demanding that the Government take control now before it’s too late. From GOP Senator Josh Hawley to Democratic socialists, Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.), there is pressure to go much further with government intervention.

None of this is new, as I’ve pointed out in my series, “The Long Journey to More.” At the start of the Industrial Age, the handicraftsmen known as  Luddites destroyed weaving machinery. Farm mechanization provoked a mass migration away from farm work. More recently, Computers connected to the internet caused an upheaval in how we do almost everything. The great economist Joseph Schumpeter called this process “Creative Destruction.”

Continue reading →